This page is optimized for a taller screen. Please rotate your device or increase the size of your browser window.

Mapping Together: Community-Based Solutions to Boundary Challenges in Indonesia

May 29, 2018

mapping togetherIndonesia is composed of 17,000 islands made up of wetlands, rugged terrain, rural villages, and dense cities, and has a contentious and costly boundary dispute problem. Overlapping land claims and confusion about administrative boundaries and jurisdiction frequently lead to conflict. Land features and oral history preserved theoretical boundary information for hundreds of years, but both have proved inefficient and increasingly unworkable in the modern era.

What happens when two villages both claim the same resource? To which village does a hamlet on a vague border belong? How can a country of 83,000 villages—only 5 percent of which are formally mapped—unlock, manage, and preserve the full value of its land and natural resources?

The answers to these questions impact village funding, service delivery, and negotiations with investors. Under the Millennium Challenge Account-Indonesia’s Participatory Mapping and Planning Projects (PMaP) 1 and 6, Abt Associates worked with more than 10,000 village representatives to map boundaries across hundreds of villages using community-based methodologies, high-tech mapping techniques, and an in-depth understanding of Indonesia’s rapidly changing legal and institutional framework.
 

Bringing Diverse Voices to the Table

PMaP’s 21-step boundary-setting process—designed by Abt—broke new ground by recognizing participation as a necessary component to solving local border conflicts. The resolution process prioritized inclusiveness, bringing young people, marginalized groups, and women to the same table as village leaders to make decisions on village boundaries and investigate the geographic and cultural histories of their villages.

In diverse Village Participation Teams (VPTs), members negotiated village boundary segments, mediated discussions, researched village history, and used GPS and drone technology to map natural resources and determine village boundary coordinates. PMaP trained VPT members in mapping technology, stakeholder engagement, data collection, and conflict mediation, laying the foundation for future economic and social change initiatives. In total, more than 1,100 people across Jambi, West Sulawesi, Sumatera Barat, and Nusa Tengarra Barat provinces were trained.
 
Looking ahead, village participation meetings will present an opportunity for village leaders—who are typically tasked with resolving boundary disputes between village members—to consult with a broad group of villagers and build relationships and forge agreements that will reduce the likelihood of future conflict. These meetings and project outcomes will ultimately help determine investment priorities for villages and the distribution of government funding.
 

Blending New Technology and Village Tradition

While stakeholders on the ground worked together, drones took to the sky, allowing villages to identify nearby roads and cultural and natural resources. Natural landmarks—like waterways, swamps, or forests--evolve over time, making them unreliable markers for permanent boundaries. GPS coordinates, satellite images/maps and physical boundary pillars enable leaders to establish a concrete record of their land for legal confirmation, which will lead to consistency for future generations.

As communities move from subjective, mutable record-keeping to permanent agreements, the community-based nature of the project will help ensure that cultural variables and tradition aren’t swept aside. Younger VPT members collaborated with village elders, researching village history to reach decisions mapped cultural resources and natural landmarks.
 

Success by the Numbers

Abt’s PMaP projects worked in 12 districts and 23 sub-districts and legalized village boundaries for a total area of 381,066.57 ha. In total, the projects have helped community leaders in Indonesia map 287 villages, produce more than 800 maps, and resolve dozens of boundary disputes and conflicts. Over the course of PMaP-6, 98 percent of the demarcated boundary segments under review achieved inter-village agreement, while the collaborative VPTs identified 2,181 critical cultural and natural resources.
 
Abt’s PMaP work set a foundation for spatial certainty and sound land-related planning and investment in Indonesia. It also received buy-in from district governments, which committed to expanding village boundary-setting practices to other sub-districts. Increased spatial certainty is enabling increased green investment—supported by MCA-Indonesia—as investors face fewer logistical challenges to working in the region. With new inter-village partnerships and mediation skills, villages across PMaP districts are equipped to negotiate and position themselves for new opportunities and growth.